Perfect Gift Ideas For the Mystery & Crime Lover

Do perfect gift ideas actually exist? At the MRC, we LOVE all things Mystery, Thriller, and True Crime. Put all those together and you have a winning shot at making us smile all day. When asked what we’d recommend as a “perfect gift” for our fellow crime junkies, we were quick to point to some rather humorous and unique gifts we’ve received or come across in the past. 

We hope these help you find the perfect gift for the mystery lover in your life. 

Perfect Gift Ideas for the Mystery And Crime Lover

*Affiliate links are used in this article. The Mystery Review Crew is an Amazon Affiliate and as such earns from qualifying purchases. See our privacy policy and disclosures for more information.

Perfect gift ideas for the Mystery and Crime Lover

For the book lover who has everything… we recommend some bags to hold it all 😉 and some other fun things to share their love of reading

We found this Evidence Bag on Amazon and this neat Personalized Leather Handbag (with so many different sizes to chose from!) from The Note Bags Company, I loved the one with a reading dragon on it.

This Reader Suncatcher is also really cute and customizable as well and are you truly a mystery lover if you don’t own a Chloroform Scented Candle

If you are looking for more normal but still wonderfully warmly scented candles, can I recommend buying them from Lamplighter Literary Creations? Not only would you support a small business, but the candles smell so good I may or may not own every one Megan releases!

Check out the Lamplighter Literary Creations Collection

Another fun idea for mystery lovers is a True Crime Activity Book for Adults, it has puzzles, brain teasers, and mysteries to solve! Plus, if your mystery lover likes true crime they might enjoy this true crime & coffee sign, these crime junkie socks, or even these crime-centric t-shirts; one for introverts and murder shows or this one that rhymes.

And if they really do like crime books they might enjoy this humorous coffee mug that is definitely crime junkie approved.

Things to decorate, things to use.

These Flameless Votive Candles are the perfect reading mood setter. Their lowlight (and remote control ability) add to the suspense; bonus points for them not actually being able to burn the house down when you get lost in a book. I also really enjoy using this rechargeable book light for my late night reading.

If you are in a hurry and would like a simple gift set already put together for you I recommend this Set of 5 Book Lovers Gifts for Readers, it comes with a mug, a bag, a journal, a candle, and an ink pen too!

Now, to help decorate their book shelves check out these neat Reading Shelf Sculptures, some beautiful Stained Glass Bookends, and a Craft kit to make their book edges stand out!

Did you know that you can gift a subscription? 

Amazon Kindle Unlimited. You have probably heard about it before, and you can actually gift it to people for 3 months, 6 months, or a year! It is truly a gift that keeps on giving to your reader so they have new stories all year long. 

Plus, if they like Audiobooks there are subscription options for those as well! I personally have one to the Barnes and Noble audiobook subscription program, but you can also give one to Amazon’s Audible in 3,6, or 12-month lengths.

If you’d like to support small businesses with your gift-giving we’d like to present a few of our favorite small shops:

Get a customized Sherlock Holmes Fans Phone Case (along with some other well-known mystery sleuths), a Mini Anxiety Bookshelf that I really enjoy shaking, and a personalized book embosser so they’ll know when the lend a book out and it won’t be another mystery to solve.

Have you seen these bookish gifts? They are called book alleys or Shelf Alleys. You can buy them pre-made or buy ones your Mystery book lover can put together themselves. 

Miniature Book Alleys we found at Barnes and Noble:

DIY Wooden Miniature Kit Cathy's Flower House ROBOTIME LLC Author

DIY Wooden Miniature Kit Cathy’s Flower House ROBOTIME LLC Author

Cathy’s Flower House is a DIY Miniature kit, it requires customers to built all parts by hands, including wooden, paper, cloth and all kinds of material, all necessary parts in included in the packaging. After built, the kit will be a nice home deceration with LED light. The item is a also good gift, recommended for 14+ teenagers and adults. Customers can also redesign the kit by themselves, changing the color or shape all by DIY. WARNING: Choking Hazard; Small Parts. Not for children under 3 years old.


DIY Miniature Bookend: Sunshine Town Hands Craft Author

DIY Miniature Bookend: Sunshine Town Hands Craft Author

Sunshine Town DIY Miniature House Book Nook Kit, with LED Lights and laser pre-cut precision pieces for teens and adults. Touch activated light switch. Assembled size: 4.5 x 7.5 x 8.6 inch. Requires 2 AAA batteries. Batteries not include.


DIY Miniature House Kit: Sam's Study Hands Craft Author

DIY Miniature House Kit: Sam’s Study Hands Craft Author

Sam’s Study Room DIY Miniature House Kit, with LED Lights. Includes cell batteries and LED lights.


Mysteries, Games, and Puzzles just go together

And how could we not include puzzles on this list? Here at the MRC Anita and I are a little obsessed with puzzles, if you hadn’t noticed :). We love how they echo the intrigue and puzzles in the books we read. Below are a few I love and personally own. My favorite brands are White Mountain, Ravensburg, Buffalo Games, and MasterPieces as the quality of their pieces hold together well and don’t tear (so far!).

Games! Board Games and Mystery Puzzles are they the perfect gift ideas for your mystery and crime lover?

Fiction: A Word Guessing Game from BN

Fiction: A Word Guessing Board Game BGT.com Author

From Barnes & Noble or Amazon.

Another couple of word-based games we’ve tried are Mysterium Board Game and a recent release is Murdle: A Board Game by Rob Grom.

This puzzle jumped out at me while pursuing the Barnes and Noble shelves its called Reader’s Paradise. So, of course I had to buy it and LOVED putting it together

Reader's Paradise Aimee Stewart Author

Reader’s Paradise Aimee Stewart Author

White Mountain Puzzles Readers Paradise – 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle The amount of detail in this painting is astonishing! You’ll be immediately drawn into this magical shop with stacks of tomes offering the classics, history, poetry, travel and much more. Find a cozy nook to settle into upstairs or downstairs and wish upon a book. If you’re lucky, the resident kitty might curl up on your lap. Artist Aimee Stewart. 1,000 pieces. Finished size 24 x 30.WISH UPON A BOOK: Be immediately drawn into this magical shop with stacks of tomes offering the classics, history, poetry, travel and much more. The amount of detail in this painting is astonishing! Adopting the title ‘Renaissance Woman’, Aimee is a self taught artist, photographer and writer who has music in her soul and daydreams in her blood. Every White Mountain Puzzle is proudly manufactured in America with a 100% customer satisfaction guarantee. All our puzzles contain unique interlocking pieces that are made of sturdy blue chipboard on recycled paper. 1000 piece puzzles measure 24×30 larger pieces for easy handling. Warnings: Choking Hazard, Has Small Parts


A Mystery inside a puzzle you say?  Well this Murder Most Puzzling: The Missing Will 500-Piece Puzzle was really a unique twist on putting together a puzzle and the Big Potato Mayhem in The Library: Book Jigsaw Puzzle was a fun mystery I did forsee. If you want to give them a real challenge we suggest this one from Misu Games Black Box Puzzle Without a Template and one of my favorite amateur sleuth’s mysterious puzzles is Murder by The Pyramids.

Anita Dickason’s A Tori Winters Series

Deadly Keepsake’s by Anita Dickason

The past becomes a deadly future.

When Tori Winters becomes the star witness in a murder trial, someone tries to kill her. Terrified, she’s not giving the killer a second chance. With all her worldly possessions packed in her car, Tori is on the run. A mysterious phone call about an inheritance leads her to Granbury. After all, who would look for her in a small, quaint Texas town?

Instead, Tori’s life is about to spin into an existence where nothing is as it seems. The historic house she inherits is steeped in secrets from the past. Secrets that may prove deadly. She’s a stranger in a strange town. Who can she trust? There is the disinherited step-grandson and the lawyer and his son. What are they hiding?

Tori’s inheritance may not be a blessing when a killer strikes again. It could be her death warrant.

On Goodreads, Barnes & Noble, Amazon, and Bookbub.

Check out other MRC Recommended Must-Read Books for your bookish mystery novel needs. 

Kristen Hannah’s The Woman. This book was unputdownable and had Kristen Hannah’s signature writing style that kept us on the edge of our seats, it is about nurses during the Vietnam War: 

A #1 bestseller on The New York Times, USA Today, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times! From the celebrated author of The Nightingale and The Four Winds comes Kristin Hannah’s The Women—at once an intimate portrait of coming of age in a dangerous time and an epic tale of a nation divided. Women can be heroes. 

When twenty-year-old nursing student Frances “Frankie” McGrath hears these words, it is a revelation. Raised in the sun-drenched, idyllic world of Southern California and sheltered by her conservative parents, she has always prided herself on doing the right thing. But in 1965, the world is changing, and she suddenly dares to imagine a different future for herself. When her brother ships out to serve in Vietnam, she joins the Army Nurse Corps and follows his path.

As green and inexperienced as the men sent to Vietnam to fight, Frankie is over-whelmed by the chaos and destruction of war. Each day is a gamble of life and death, hope and betrayal; friendships run deep and can be shattered in an instant. In war, she meets—and becomes one of—the lucky, the brave, the broken, and the lost.

But war is just the beginning for Frankie and her veteran friends. The real battle lies in coming home to a changed and divided America, to angry protesters, and to a country that wants to forget Vietnam.

The Women is the story of one woman gone to war, but it shines a light on all women who put themselves in harm’s way and whose sacrifice and commitment to their country has too often been forgotten. A novel about deep friendships and bold patriotism, The Women is a richly drawn story with a memorable heroine whose idealism and courage under fire will come to define an era.

On Goodreads, Barnes and Noble, Amazon, and Bookbub.

Korina Moss’s New Cheese Shop Mystery Fondue or Die

In Korina Moss’s Fondue or Die, the lazy, hazy, dairy days of summer are coming to a close in the Sonoma Valley. . . and so is someone’s life.

The small town of Yarrow Glen’s neighbor, Lockwood, hosts an annual Labor Day weekend bash: Dairy Days. And Willa Bauer and her cheese shop, Curds & Whey, refuse to miss out on the fun. Willa is thrilled to celebrate her favorite thing—she is a cheesemonger after all—and this festival goes all out: butter sculptures, goat races, cheese wheel relays, even a Miss Dairy pageant. Too bad the pageant runner, Nadine, is treating Dairy Days prep like it’s fondue or die and is putting everyone around her on edge. When Willa finds Nadine’s dead body under years’ worth of ceramic milk jugs, the police aren’t sure whether the death was an accident. But fingers are pointing at Willa’s employee, Mrs. Schultz, who steps in to help the pageant after Nadine’s death. Someone wanted Nadine out of the whey, and Willa is going to find out who.

On Goodreads, Barnes & Noble, Amazon, and Bookbub.

A true crime novel by Frank Figliuzzi, Long Haul: Hunting the Highway Serial Killers – This is a book for the murder mystery enthusiast who doesn’t mind a good dose of reality. 

From the FBI’s former assistant director, a shocking journey to the dark side of America’s highways, revealing the FBI Highway Serial Killings Initiative’s hunt for the long-haul truckers behind an astonishing 850 murders–and counting.

In 2004, the FBI was tipped off to a gruesome pattern of unsolved murders along American roadways. Today at least 850 homicides have been linked to a solitary breed of predators: long-haul truck drivers. They have been given names like the “Truck Stop Killer,” who rigged a traveling torture chamber in the rear of his truck and is suspected to have killed fifty women, and “The Interstate Strangler,” who once answered a phone call from his mother while killing one of his dozen victims.

The crisis was such that the FBI opened a special unit, the Highway Serial Killings Initiative. In many cases, the victims—often at-risk women—are picked up at truck stops in one jurisdiction, sexually assaulted and murdered in another, and dumped along a highway in a third place. The transient nature of the offenders and multiple jurisdictions involved make these cases incredibly difficult to solve.

Based on his own on-the-ground research and drawing on his twenty-five-year career as an FBI special agent, Frank Figliuzzi investigates the most terrifying cases. He also rides in a big-rig with a long-haul trucker for thousands of miles, gaining an intimate understanding of the life and habits of drivers and their roadside culture. And he interviews the courageous trafficked victims of these crimes, and their inspiring efforts to now help others avoid similar fates.

Long Haul is a gripping exploration of a violent, disordered world hiding in plain sight, and the heroes racing to end the horror. It will forever unsettle how you travel on the road.

On Goodreads, Barnes and Noble, Amazon, and Bookbub.

Check out this collection featuring Female protagonists: Women Crime Writers: Eight Suspense Novels of the 1940s & 50s: A Library of America Boxed Set

Though women crime and suspense writers dominate today’s best seller lists, the extraordinary creations of the mid-century female pioneers of the genre are largely unknown. Their work, influential in its day and still vibrant and extraordinarily riveting, is long overdue for rediscovery. Now The Library of America makes these classic books available in a deluxe two-volume collector’s edition. From the 1940s, here are Vera Caspary’s famous career girl mystery Laura; Helen Eustis’s intricate campus thriller The Horizontal Man; Dorothy B. Hughes’s In a Lonely Place, the terrifyingly intimate portrait of a serial killer; and Elisabeth Sanxay Holding’s The Blank Wall, in which a wife in wartime is forced to take extreme measures when her family is threatened.

The 1950s volume includes Charlotte Armstrong’s Mischief, the nightmarish drama of a child entrusted to a psychotic babysitter; Patricia Highsmith’s brilliant The Blunderer, which tracks the perverse parallel lives of two men driven toward murder; Margaret Millar’s Beast in View, a relentless study in madness; and Dolores Hitchens’s Fools’ Gold, a hard-edged tale of robbery and redemption.

On Goodreads and Amazon

Special Edition or “Collector’s Editions” Mystery Books round out our holiday shopping most often as a good mystery is a unique experience few will forget. 

Some of our favorites are from The Folio Society and include beloved favorites from Agatha Christie including, some of her Hercule Poirot mysteries (Murder on the Orient Express is my FAVORITE!), along with mysteries from Ian Flemming (think 007), and a little romantic mystery with Rebecca by Daphne Demure.

Every reader loves getting some new books, whether it’s some special edition classics like Nancy Drew, along with mysteries from Arthur Conan Doyle (the author of Sherlock Holmes), Agatha Christie, or some completely new murder mysteries. Books truly do make the perfect present for mystery fans.

And lastly, a physical book subscription. Some of our personal favorites are Book of The Month as they have a wide selection of books to choose from each month and they usually have a good selection of mysteries.

I LOVE LitJoy Crate for it’s whimsical editions and their gothic book set is AMAZING; you can use this link to get $5 off your LitJoy purchase. 

We hope this list helps you with a gift guide of sorts to start shopping for the mystery readers in your life. 

– Anita & Kimberly

Share your love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *